home  
     
Slide 110 Interventions for Tuberculosis Control and Elimination
next Next
previous Previous
beginning First
last Last

An alternative, much less expensive approach to assess the protective effect of BCG is the use of a retrospective study design. The best known example is the case-control study.  Here one starts with the outcome and looks at the exposure.

Cases of tuberculosis (the outcome) are assembled and a group that is comparable in every respect but the outcome (they must be free of disease) is chosen as a control group. The prevalence of BCG vaccination is then assessed and compared in the two groups. Rates cannot be calculated as this type of study is not population-based. The measure here is the odds ratio. It approximates the relative risk for rare diseases. The protective effectiveness is similarly calculated as 1 minus the odds ratio, usually expressed as a percentage.

Case-control studies are more likely to be biased than prospective studies as the selection of appropriate controls is often hampered with difficulties that cannot always be easily overcome.

   
Go to top

Last update: September 29, 2010